WWE's Heart Problem: Can Anyone Fill John Cena's Shoes?
Kevin Berge, Nov 18, 2025
The road to Survivor Series: WarGames is heating up, and the November 17th Raw on Netflix delivered a night of surprises, returns, and emotional moments. But amidst the chaos, one question loomed large: Can WWE recapture the genuine emotion it's been missing?
John Cena's Final Raw: A Celebration of Heart
John Cena's final Raw appearance wasn't just a match; it was a testament to the power of authenticity. The electric atmosphere in Madison Square Garden as Cena walked out, the organic celebration of his legacy alongside Rey Mysterio and Sheamus, and his emotional farewell – all pointed to a truth WWE seems to have forgotten: Fans crave genuine connection.
Cena's segment wasn't about intricate storylines or manufactured drama; it was about the raw emotion of a legend saying goodbye to what he loves. This kind of heartfelt moment has been sorely lacking in WWE since WrestleMania 40, with the exception of Cody Rhodes' organic rise. But even Rhodes, despite his talent, seems to be missing that spark of genuine joy lately. His title reigns feel too scripted, too calculated.
And this is the part most people miss: WWE's problem isn't a lack of talent. It's a lack of heart.
Who Can Carry the Torch?
The question now is, who can step up and fill the void Cena leaves behind? CM Punk, despite his veteran status, often feels more jaded than joyful on screen. Jey Uso, while popular, struggles to fully express himself on the mic. Sami Zayn's infectious love for wrestling is relegated to midcard storylines, never truly taking center stage.
But here's where it gets controversial: Is WWE's creative team to blame? Are they too focused on corporate interests and advertisement to allow wrestlers to truly connect with the audience? Shouldn't the men and women risking their bodies every week be allowed to showcase their genuine passion?
Wasted Opportunities and Missed Connections
The 'Last Time is Now' tournament, hyped as a platform for surprise and excitement, has fallen flat. Returns like Dolph Ziggler and Zack Ryder felt like afterthoughts, booked to lose in forgettable matches rather than celebrated as returning heroes. WWE seems more interested in pushing established stars than honoring Cena's legacy or giving these veterans a proper send-off.
Gunther vs. Cena: A Missed Opportunity?
While Gunther is a phenomenal talent, his match against Cena feels like a missed opportunity. The 'Ring General' deserves a more focused storyline after his injury, not a rushed retirement match. LA Knight, with his charisma and connection to Cena, would have been a more fitting choice, but WWE seems hesitant to fully embrace him.
Maxxine Dupri: Champion or Temporary High?
Maxxine Dupri's Intercontinental Championship win was a feel-good moment, but questions remain. Can she carry the title with the same gravitas as Becky Lynch or Lyra Valkyria? Will WWE give her the platform to prove herself, or will she be overshadowed by bigger names like AJ Lee or Roxanne Perez?
WarGames: Relying on Old Tricks
The addition of Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns to WarGames is a classic WWE move – relying on part-time stars to boost interest in a lackluster storyline. While their presence adds star power, it doesn't address the underlying issue: WWE needs to build compelling narratives around its full-time roster.
The Future of WWE: Heart Over Hype
WWE needs to remember what makes wrestling special. It's not just about flashy moves and big names; it's about the connection between performers and fans. Let the wrestlers be themselves, let their passion shine through. Only then can WWE truly recapture the magic that made it a global phenomenon.
What do you think? Can WWE find its heart again? Who do you see as the next John Cena? Let us know in the comments below!
